Crowd-sourced crime solving.... Geez can anyone explain why I wasn't a consultant on this upcoming new show - Wisdom of the Crowd? (Though for sure, I'm looking forward to it.)
Second question: why do so many previews give away almost the whole story? I hope this one will be as good as Person of Interest was... only with an important difference. I hope that its core message is one that we actually need. A confidence-building notion that we -- all of us working together in the open -- are potentially very powerful.
Speaking of New Era crime solving... how about..
== “Pre-Crime at South by Southwest! ==
Are any of you members of the fantastic culture/arts/tech festival South by Southwest? If you, you get to help choose some of the events through the “panel-picker” page. Naturally, I hope you’ll vote for one that I’m scheduled to be on: “Pre-Crime: It's Not Just Science Fiction Anymore.” Here’s the writeup … and a link to vote.
Second question: why do so many previews give away almost the whole story? I hope this one will be as good as Person of Interest was... only with an important difference. I hope that its core message is one that we actually need. A confidence-building notion that we -- all of us working together in the open -- are potentially very powerful.
Speaking of New Era crime solving... how about..
== “Pre-Crime at South by Southwest! ==
Are any of you members of the fantastic culture/arts/tech festival South by Southwest? If you, you get to help choose some of the events through the “panel-picker” page. Naturally, I hope you’ll vote for one that I’m scheduled to be on: “Pre-Crime: It's Not Just Science Fiction Anymore.” Here’s the writeup … and a link to vote.
“In Philip K. Dick’s 1956 “The Minority Report,”
murder was eradicated due to the “Pre-Crime Division,” which anticipated and
prevented crime before it happened. Sixty years later, elements of pre-crime
cybersecurity technology are already in place. But how do we toe the line
between safety and Big Brother? This panel will discuss the history of
predictive analytics, privacy implications of monitoring and how AI/machine learning
will shape society in the future.”
== Should we fret about the cameras? ==
Back in the eighties, I witnessed video cameras sprouting
like crocuses, all over Great Britain. The same thing happened in Paris, in the
early nineties, and I began pondering the concepts that would later make their
way into my book, The Transparent Society: Will Technology Make Us Choose Between Privacy and Freedom? Since then, The U.S. has become just as dense with
cameras overlooking almost every street
-- one area where Moore’s Law is still in full force, as the cams every
year get smaller, faster, better, cheaper, more mobile and vastly more
numerous.
Only there’s a crucial difference. In most U.S. cities, the
vast majority of cameras are privately owned. There’s still surveillance! (And
elsewhere I talk about how important it is to keep and enhance our
“sousveillance” power to look back!) But most of the time, the authorities must
knock on doors and ask: “may we please see your footage?”
In the case of the Boston Marathon bombing, every single
person or business that was asked fell all over themselves to help!
On the other hand, during the highly controversial Seattle “police riot” some years back, many companies and private citizens muttered: “Hell no, go get your court order.” That difference could be crucial, positively or negatively. But citizens -- sorry "subjects" -- in Britain don't have the choice. Same number of cams, but a very different society.
On the other hand, during the highly controversial Seattle “police riot” some years back, many companies and private citizens muttered: “Hell no, go get your court order.” That difference could be crucial, positively or negatively. But citizens -- sorry "subjects" -- in Britain don't have the choice. Same number of cams, but a very different society.
Oh, but now we see
change afoot. In Detroit, Project Greenlight encourages businesses to put up
city operated, standardized surveillance units. Companies that are part of Project Greenlight send live video to directly to Detroit police. Police can access them, monitoring them from
the real time crime center at Detroit Public
Safety Headquarters.
“Project Greenlight went into place in January 2016. According
to city officials, a recent study shows the original eight Project Greenlight
stations continue to see a nearly 40% reduction in violent crime. Project
Greenlight was also the key to an arrest after a wild shoot out at a gas station in March 2016.
Since then, it has expanded to more than 100 businesses and continues to grow.” reports local Detroit news.
Alas, as you might
expect, they keep upping the ante.
“The city of Detroit and the Detroit Police Department are
considering making Project Greenlight mandatory for any business that's open
after 10 p.m. Police say it's helped to curb violent crime but the plan to make
it mandatory is raising privacy concerns,” reports Ryan Ermanni.
Is this trend inevitable? Of course it is. The difference between the U.S. and Britain was temporary, after all. Still, it is the habit that matters. We must maintain the habit of looking back.
Is this trend inevitable? Of course it is. The difference between the U.S. and Britain was temporary, after all. Still, it is the habit that matters. We must maintain the habit of looking back.
== Open Science - Citizen Science ==
I’ve been asked to comment on the rise of “open science,” a
fascinating topic. There is an irony:
1. The one monotonic trend of the 20th Century
was the professionalization of everything. This gave us spectacular benefits of
both scale and specialization, but it could not be maintained because it is
essentially zero-sum. A skilled person must be one thing or else another.
2. Cracks began to appear in the late 20th as
hobbies, pastimes, avocations began to burgeon in positive-sum ways. ("I
can be several things - a professional in my day job and almost professional at one or more pastimes.") Today, amid a burgeoning Age of Amateurs, we see the worst rigidity of professional castes crumbling. Most sciences now have processes that welcome input and data collection and even analysis by
individual and affiliated amateur scientists, participating in well-organized mixed projects with professionals.
Moreover, this trend refutes all the hoary accusations that we are "decadent" or losing contact with older wisdom. There are more blacksmiths, sword-makers and hand looms today than at any point in 100 years. Heck, more horses! While those who are critical of the modern era have (on average) tended toward obesity, many (perhaps most) of the supposedly decadent modernists engage in rising amounts of physical activity. Some of those activities -- like jumping our of airplanes with surfboards -- may be clinically crazy... but ain't it cool?
individual and affiliated amateur scientists, participating in well-organized mixed projects with professionals.
Moreover, this trend refutes all the hoary accusations that we are "decadent" or losing contact with older wisdom. There are more blacksmiths, sword-makers and hand looms today than at any point in 100 years. Heck, more horses! While those who are critical of the modern era have (on average) tended toward obesity, many (perhaps most) of the supposedly decadent modernists engage in rising amounts of physical activity. Some of those activities -- like jumping our of airplanes with surfboards -- may be clinically crazy... but ain't it cool?
3. There is a dark side to the amateurism trend. Scurrilous
forces in society are now waging propaganda war against all skilled, fact-using
castes.The "war on science" is only the tip of the iceberg, as expertise
itself is slurred.
So here's the irony. We needed the
reduction in guild categorization that was threatening to hamper progress. The
Age of Amateurs and opening of fields, like science, to input from bright and
earnest outsiders, will benefit civilization. This is a point that I
raise in my book: "The Transparent Society: Will Technology Make Us ChooseBetween Privacy and Freedom?"
On the other hand, the 20th Century's
professionalization of expertise was what brought us to this party. Waves
of amateurs can augment skilled elites usefully, and challenge them
beneficially! But it is pure suicide to denigrate every clade of people
who know their fields and have spent their lives developing stunning levels of
skill. Scientists, teachers, journalists, doctors, civil servants, law
professionals, military officers... they can be mistaken, from time to time! And they always merit
watching...
... but it is the critic who bears the burden
of proof, when he says: "I read a couple of articles on a political site, and now I know more about
this than folks who have spent their life gathering data and comparing competing models and understanding the field."
See more of my missives:
== Artificial intelligence ==
Get ready for the first robot empathy crisis: Generally a not-bad summary about my
talk at the AI Conference in San Francisco, if oversimplifying in a number of ways.. The one glaring error is that I never said
you should join a dozen NGOs to save the world for you for $50/month each!
That's a lot for most people!
What I said was that you can find a dozen organizations that will actively represent your interests in how the world can be improved, and set them to work doing what you think needs doing for $30 to $50 each per YEAR, annual membership dues. That's a big difference!
That's a lot for most people!
What I said was that you can find a dozen organizations that will actively represent your interests in how the world can be improved, and set them to work doing what you think needs doing for $30 to $50 each per YEAR, annual membership dues. That's a big difference!
Sure, lots of folks can and should give
more. But if you are a middle class
person and not doing that much - that basic, minimal engagement - then you have
no right to bitch about the state of the world.
See more about this in my article: Saving the world through Proxy Activism.
But go to the source, of course, of course. For this talk -- How Might Artificial Intelligence Come About? -- I squeezed the topics - if not the details - of my hourlong AI talk for IBM's World of Watson into half an hour. Could only do that with a very elevated audience.
But go to the source, of course, of course. For this talk -- How Might Artificial Intelligence Come About? -- I squeezed the topics - if not the details - of my hourlong AI talk for IBM's World of Watson into half an hour. Could only do that with a very elevated audience.
And finally... This essay makes a case that there is a difference between a “leaker” and a righteous “whistle blower.” Citing both
James Comey and Reality Winner as recent examples, the author suggests a
discrete difference that is actually (I assert) much more murky and part of a
very broad spectrum.



