Lack of time - and the imminence of voting - means that I'll do same as last time... offer a few pungent links and even more pungent images that I've collected across years.
The previous two postings offer some of the best. (My favorite shows Trump's giddy love fests with Kim Jong Un, Vlad Putin, MBS and every variety of tyrant.) Here I'll also repeat my text-rich 1-pager of challenges for those still rationalizing obscene treason, but who may still have glimmers of residual sanity that might be reached.
SCROLL DOWN FOR THE MARCH OF THE JPEGS!
== News blips ==
"Hegseth reportedly fires U.S. top military planner as Trump downplays Iran peace talks." Since day one of Trump I've predicted his mafia would try to bend the US officer corps (USOC) to its will by every means. Yes, I speak often about blackmail, which is standard for all but a few GOP politicians. But they are stymied by the professionalism and sagacity of the USOC. And hence, in Trump#2 one of the first things they did was fire almost all of the JAGs who can advise officers about illegal orders. Now it's up to the courageous to STAY at their posts and demand a court martial! Hegs won't dare!
"Trump Claims He’ll Soon Officially Ban The Term ‘Artificial Intelligence." Idiotic on so many levels though indicative of supreme, inperial yearnings. One of you in comments suggested last time: "I'd reverse SI and use Imitation Sapience (IS). Has a nice Bletchley ring to it as well." Anyway, do see my AI book: AIlien Minds.
Remember my uplifted 'neo-dogs'? Well, some eager-beager, gung-ho contractors are pushing new kinds of military/police dogs, even cyborgs, that might be effective in combat... or else at controlling civilians...
*** Californians: Here's a ballot recommendation list that I trust. Plus two points:
1. All of the state-level judges were appointed by Jerry Brown or by Newsom. August and sagacious professionals who show just how diametrically opposite the parties have become.
2. I agree with Newsom that Proposition 40 - the Billionaire Wealth Tax - is flawed. It shows no flexibility to prevent the zillionaires from simply leaving. Nevertheless i'll vote yes on 40 for one reason, in order to fire a shot over the moguls' bows and get them to negotiate.
Actually, passing 40 won't matter that much. What matters far more is to defeat 41 & 42! If those pass, zillionaires will NEVER negotiate!
* And disease! Correlation is not causation. But Covid hit while Trump (at-best) fumbled. Now? Measles, Dengue, Screw-worm, and literally a dozen other infectious plagues that had been driven out of the USA are swarming back while the Foxites slash the CDC and all our other health and emergency services. And POLIO was on the ropes, nearly extinct... till resurging where US efforts were sabotaged under Trump. This takes very special stoopid. Or else sabotage.
== Images that zing! ==
Okay... here's a bunch. When your MAGA says "You have your 'facts' and jpegs and and I have mine!" answer with 'My assertions are fact checkable with $$$ wager stakes on the line. Will you do that? Back em up with cash? With accountability?" Watch him flee! Or else he might decide to learn something.
Drag these onto desktop to expand and share.
And finally... for now... my own prompted meme below reminds you all of a word that is feared by any MAGA who knows a little history. It's up to them whether the coming Appomattox will end this nasty 9th phase of the recurring, 248 year US Civil War with calmness and "malice toward none," which we will do, if the travesties and betrayals stop.
(Let's be clear. If America - the blue/sanity - wins, reds can count on our resumed generosity. If they win this phase solidly, I will be dead within a year and 1930s Germany will commence, as explicitly planned by Project 2025.)
But nothing will stop that word coming true, one way or another. We will not go back to 6000 years of cruel, unsapient feudalism. (Hear that, oligarchs? Even your "Event" will turn our rage upon every 'hidden' prepper fortress.*)
Wear your blue Union kepi with pride!
Let us return to the GI Bill society that had the finest market economy and more freedom, creativity and incremental progress than any other across all of time... till GOPpers trashed it.
If we go back to that generous, fair, scientific, tolerant and fact-centered nation and society, then we may all yet -- including you -- inherit the stars.
* A Canticle for Lie-bitches....









242 comments:
1 – 200 of 242 Newer› Newest»"I'd reverse SI and use Imitation Sapience (IS). Has a nice Bletchley ring to it as well."
For myself, I go with 'Natural Intelligence', particularly after Google got caught destroying some Finnish shrubbery.
Whenever I see the term 'Natural Intelligence', I feel physical pain. It takes me back to my stroke recovery days and the multiple mountains I had to climb.
Also, although not Finnish, I am a tree hugger (grew up in the Boreal Outback).
Also, I'm knee-deep in pondering an NCM (next gen LLM) in Forth.
Just checking in to reassure our fine host that he is not a target of resurgent fascism, as the US Republican Party is the most semitophilic political party in US history, only to hear reports of a new German Police Blitzkrieg into Poland yesterday on a 'anti-fascist & pro-democracy' government rescue mission.
Perhaps DerOger can clarify?
Either way, I'll be taking some time off for personal issues, but I'll check in later, assuming that any of us survive the coming progressive Anti-Fascist Reich & the EU's ongoing diversity riots.
Best
"... the US Republican Party is the most semitophilic political party in US history..."
Not quite. The Republican Party uses anti-anti-Semitism an an excuse to be openly antagonistic to Muslims, both here in the States and in the Middle East. That's not the same thing as being friendly to Jews. In fact, a large subset openly blames Israel for tricking us into wars, and not only the current one in Iran.
Republicans opposed Truman helping to birth Israel. They ran the country clubs and civic orgs that excluded Jews. The Bush family is a cadet branch of the Saudi Royal House, using our military as sepoy troops for the ones who fill every Arab textbook and kid-show with vows of death to all Jews. So... no.
As for the subset of Israel support by US Fundies, we're perfectly aware of the reason. They want the Temple rebuilt so the world can end and 99% of Jews will then go to Hell. Get bent, loopy...
...but travel safe! You can be amusing at times and make me smug over my tolerance and contrariness at Contrary Brin.
Been busy politically. Taking a break tonight.
Ran into a neat dark matter summary video.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QXXqSh5qAuA
Whatever you have heard, there is nothing about a special police activity in Poland in the main media, so please provide a source.
Note that in the border regions both the Brandenburg state police and the Polish police have formed mutual patrol forces in the past, so maybe that is what Locum has stumbled over.
The only noteworthy news from Poland is that Tusk has deposed the Polish Supreme court, and created both a constitutional crisis as well as protests.
I intend voting tomorrow - for our parliamentary election that is
We have a large number of parties - the right-wing idiots are in charge just now but we do hope to dump them
The main parties - National on the right and Labour on the left
One of the smaller parties - The Opportunity Party - has a lot of excellent ideas - but IMHO it is more important to get the right-wing idiots out of power so I will be voting Labour
Ideal would be a Labour/Green/Top coalition - Labour on its own has been too timid to make the larger changes needed
One US state - Alaska - has rank choice voting as in the Hugo Awards. It let's you vote 1st for love and 2nsd against the monster.
Or 1st for John Sullivan and 2nd for John Sullivan if you're confused. :)
Alaska has a long history of association with 'multiple Sullivans.'
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sullivan_brothers
We have MMP - so I vote for my local MP - I am in a very rural area so National will probably get that
And I have a "Party Vote"
When the dust all settles the number of "Party Votes" is collated and if a party has less seats than the percentage of votes some extra seats are created to be filled by that party
I like the system it means that we almost always have a coalition in charge
Tomorrow, we'll discover just what God in Heaven has in store!
One more dawn.
One more day.
One day more!
'Nuff said.
Since I have a record here of this sort of stuff, my election forecast for posterity:
House 228D - 207R
Senate 55D+I - 45R
Kotek (OR Gov) by 1%
SCOTUS(6-3) keeps DoJ-inteference cases unseated until they work through the courts in blatant violation of the Elections Clause but no true violations ever adjudicated after appeals.
And so matthew reveals his core OPTIMISM! Go figure! If that were true, then what I devoutly wish is a dozen FLIPPED STATEHOUSE CHAMBERS!
AND RESULTS SO OVERWHELMING THAT THE PROJECT 2025 TRAITORS WILL CANCEL THEIR SUPER 9/11 OR REICHSTAG FIRE. Sorry I am having trouvle with caps lock...
Hi Matthew,
You're being a bit optimistic, IMHO.
I would be very happy (from overseas) to see a Fetterman-proof 52-48 Senate, somewhere around a 222-213 House, and a couple of flipped Governorships (ESPECIALLY if these included Texas).
By the way, for everybody's information, here in Australia Ranked Choice (we call it Preferential) Voting is used all the time. People get used to it.
Fingers crossed. Both for the actual voting results, and the time after should the polls be correct.
Re: optimism, I saw a hopeful sign in town (literally) - a billboard reading "thinking of leaving MAGA? You're not alone", with a web address for online help.
Pappenheimer
P.S. the GQP needs to buried in blue ballots. I voted via drop box last week
Just returned from voting in person. Light crowd , skillful volunteers, smooth process, clear paper receipt after the touchscreen. I have seen nothing in the news about bullies deterring people at polling places in cities.
Trump howled "I could have won Vietnam in a week by bombing Ho Chi Minh City!" Um, by bombing our allies in Saigon? (The city's previous name.) I love it. He just crushed any remaining like in the US military.
In regard to Haley whatshername and John Fetterman and Tulsi Gabbard, this falls under "Why didn't I think of this before?"
I think we can insist that a politician may only run as a member of the party he or she was assigned on his or her birth certificate. :)
Losing both the house and senate won't make trump a lame duck.
It will make him a cornered animal.
We are about to find out how batshit insane this cruel evil narcissist can get.
If both houses flip, a number of people will think they'll have some cover for objecting to or dragging out the insanities.
If the Senate flips, I want all of Two Scoops goons impeached so the new Senate can weigh in on possible replacements (if any).
That's VERY optimistic for the Senate, but it goes on my wish list anyway.
Alas, Alfred. If any current powerful GOPpers (beyond Massie, MTG and a few others) were going to decouple from Trump they would have, by now. I deem my Blackmail Hypothesis utterly confirmed. If we do see defectiomns, it will mean that the kompromat is held by someone other than Trump himself. That holder might order them to distance themselves, for strategic reasons. But they will do nothing about actual power.
I'm already seeing comments on FOX that translate as...
"Trump said to vote as if he were on the ballot... and that's exactly what's happening."
I still want the goon impeachments. I don't think the new Senate will be quite as loyal to protecting his piss-poor choices for cabinet seats and other appointments. I am certain he won't be convicted, but I'lll settle (for now) for stripping away some of his lackeys as that sends a signal to the others that they aren't safe.
Tomorrow... I shall try to be civil.
Tonight... I am in a barbarian mood.
Crush your enemies.
See them driven before you.
Hear their lamentations.
@Alfred,
Wasn't it "...hear the lamentations of their women"?
I don't want to get too happy ahead of time, and I won't sleep well until I see a Fetterman-proof majority in the Senate.
That said, tonight feels like 2008 about the time that Pennsylvania and North Carolina (and then freakin' Indiana) went for Obama.
Darlene Graham is toast in South Carolina. Ossoff in Georgia and Roy Cooper in North Carolina are done deals. And John Cornyn (though not Paxton) has just called James Talarico to congratulate him on winning his Senate seat for Texas!
Susan Collins just might hang on in Maine, but it looks as if the good team will pick up Kansas and Iowa and possibly Nebraska. Michigan is close, but Al-Sayed has been consistently ahead. We'll see on that one, but the anti-Al-Sayed argument has been anti-Muslim rhetoric, apparently forgetting that as goes the Arab vote, so goes Michigan.
I don't see a lot of governor and House statistics, but it appears that Amy Acton has beaten Vivek Ramaswamy in Ohio, and of course my own governor J.B. Pritzker won handily in Illinois. I'm curious to see how the House numbers stack up when California soon reports.
"See" you in the morning.
""Trump said to vote as if he were on the ballot... and that's exactly what's happening."
Heh. I've also been reminded that Lindsey Graham truthfully said that if Republicans elect Trump, they will be destroyed, "and we will deserve it."
Texas has just shown Elon Musk what money cannot buy.
Yes... but I'm hearing lamentations of their men too... and more than a little happy about it.
To paraphrase crystal Gayle: "Don't it turn my red state blue?"
Book of revelatios 12 seems appropriate:
Therefore rejoice, you heavens
and you who dwell in them!
But woe to the earth and the sea,
because the devil has gone down to you!
He is filled with fury,
because he knows that his time is short.”
There is a joke circulating over here in the comment sections: "After 8 months of war, there is a regime change. But not in Iran."
Alaska and Mississippi are still counting. As of now, in the latter the Dem candidate leads by 40 or so votes.
Texas turned completely blue with Dems winning all state wide races.
Without Texas the GOP has zero chance of winning the white house.
Ever.
Quote for the victorious Democrats from Dr Who:
https://youtu.be/67HNv9T5rYw?is=zLBzJlEPrLKxaTAN
"So long as there's mercy. Always mercy."
Do MAGA deserve mercy?
Of course not.
Would they have shown us mercy if they had won?
Of course not.
We show mercy anyways,
We show mercy if only because it is in our interests to do so.
https://www.electoral-vote.com/evp2026/Items/Nov04-1.html
05:27 am EST What an unbelievable election. We thought there would likely be a blue wave, maybe verging on a blue tsunami, but that was a blue monsoon. On Wednesday, the media is going to have many stories about the blue team's success in the elections. On Thursday, they will pivot back to "Democrats in disarray" and "Here's how winning nearly every competitive election is actually bad for the Democrats."
Sad, but probably true. Still, nothing yucks my yum today.
"Without Texas the GOP has zero chance of winning the white house."
I have suspected for some time that the moment it looked like Texas would go blue, the legislature would change their method of determining electoral votes to the Maine/Nebraska model. I have not heard results of local races in other states, but I wonder if the Texas state legislature will not be as firmly Republican as it has been.
It looks as if the 11 states of the old Confederacy are tied 5-5 as to which party they just sent to the Senate. Mississippi will be the tie-breaker.
Here we are Wednesday morning, and Mississippi hasn't been called yet. The Senate race there is tied at 48.9% apiece. In Mississippi for gosh sakes!
It's about time that "unprecedented" breaks our way!
matthew:
House 228D - 207R
Senate 55D+I - 45R
Kotek (OR Gov) by 1%
Alfred:
That's VERY optimistic for the Senate, but it goes on my wish list anyway.
matthew called it pretty well! We're currently at 54 Dem Senators, and while I'm not counting on it, Alaska or Mississippi could still surprise us.
And according to the New York Times, we've already got 228 Reps, with many still uncalled. It's likely to be more than that.
Having said that we must never lower our guard.
The last 10 years have shown that fully 1/3 of Americans are racist a-holes of sub normal intelligence. "Deplorable" doesn't begin to describe these people.
But MAGA voters are mostly poorly educated and elderly rural white people in poor health whose health care is about to be taken from them by Trump's own "big beautiful bill". That is karmic justice that they richly deserve.
MAGA voters won't be around much longer.
It's said that before a fire dies out it flares up one last time. MAGA was the flare up of dying white nationalist racism.
Dr Brin:
"And so matthew reveals his core OPTIMISM! Go figure! I"
I'd say he reveals his core REALISM! He's not just optimistic or pessimistic as a principle--he calls 'em how he sees 'em. And he's (mostly) shown good instincts in that regard.
"I'm hearing lamentations of their men too"
* Spit take! *
And Trump is probably secretly relieved that he's off the hook for those $5000 checks. :)
We made it to 250 years, but last night it ended. People no longer want freedom, they want to be told how to live their lives.
Now we get to live through Atlas Shrugged.
We will regain our freedom, but it won’t be pretty.
https://www.electoral-vote.com/evp2026/Items/Nov04-1.html
Other trending memes: (1) This is all for you, dog who Kristi Noem shot; (2) Mitch McConnell has also turned blue and (3) Susan Collins' reign of concern is over.
Heh. Especially (2)
"...they want to be told how to live their lives."
No sense of irony.
Feel free to join Elon in Musk's Gulch on Mars.
@Larry Hart
It is no longer safe to reply:
Top House Dem Exposes Revenge Plot With These Two Simple Words
Lawyer Up
https://townhall.com/news/mattvespa/2026/11/04/top-house-dem-exposes-revenge-plot-with-these-two-simple-words-n2685904
"Top House Dem Exposes Revenge Plot"
Excuse me? Exactly who has been using the DOJ for personal revenge, however incompetently, for the past two years?
Lawyer Up
Sounds like good advice to actual criminals. Interesting how you right-wingers suddenly claim law enforcement is persecution when you're the lawbreakers.
He was never going to pay them anyways.
And his gullible followers would be too stupid to notice.
And
They Just Want Affordability? Scott Galloway Called for the Execution of Elon Musk Last Night.
https://townhall.com/news/amy-curtis/2026/11/04/scott-galloway-execute-elon-musk-n2685906
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/03/us/politics/trump-midterm-election-results.html
“I wasn’t on the ticket,” Mr. Trump said in an interview with The New York Times on Tuesday night before polls had closed in parts of the country. “And because I wasn’t on the ticket, we couldn’t get enough people out to vote.”
Yeah, that's why they lost, huh?
They thought, "If only Donald could get a crack at that.
They'd put up even money now with Donald at the bat."
Sorry, do you have a point?
Well, we used to execute traitors.
The French also had their own method for dealing with the oppressive, wealthy elite.
Or billionaires can chose to pay their fair share of taxes and stop undermining/poisoning our democracy with their bribe money.
I read the tea leaves early last night and went to bed after celebratory ice cream.
I woke up this morning and wondered, "Should I get a second bowl?"
Please note that in the SC and TX senate races, rumpT shot the GQP in the...
"foot" by pressing for the worst possible candidates (SC with a completely inexperienced candidate and TX with a monstrously corrupt one). I can only savor the "Downfall" remake scene going on in the White House right now. And the resume updating in the Capitol Building.
Pappenheimer
P.S. looks like there's a new troll sighting here. Won't be feeding this one either.
P.P.S. had the best damned Traveller session in years this past Sunday. 3 species crew (4 if you count Zhodani as a separate subspecies) and a ship captain with PTSD. "They won't let me leave Imperial Space? navigator, I want you to deliberately misjump!"
addendum/piece de resistance:
Rumors afloat in the Navy (pun intended) that the 'Trump' class "battleship" won't ever see a keel laid down. Good riddance to a dumb idea.
Pappenheimer
Elon musk wasted a half billion dollars in a vain attempt to subvert democracy
That makes me very happy.
He is also probably regretting his decision to move to Texas.
I wonder if joe Rogan will follow him when he leaves.
What a relief. It took too long, but finally we really did get a blue wave. I think I'll celebrate this evening. With a good drink.
We've had some flooding in our area since Monday, so I wasn't paying much attention to election results. The past two evenings on my way home from the office I had to ride through water up to my knees to get through my neighborhood to my house. And my bike is relatively tall. Seeing the results this morning, they were a complete surprise. I was damn near in tears.
"Elon musk wasted a half billion dollars in a vain attempt to subvert democracy"
Mangling Evita:
It's an ill wind that blows nobody good.
The news may be bad for one South African lad,
But it's good news for network tv.
"Seeing the results this morning, ...
As George Carlin said of "Indian sergeants" (in an admittedly ahistorical bit),
"Just because they started in Manhattan and wound up defending Santa Monica doesn't mean they were bad."
Just noting that there's now a hard time limit on emplacing Project 2025, deporting everyone with more than a deep tan, and selling off the US for parts. I've having no fun reading 'the Nerd Reich' because this is what the tech billionaires wanted and still want; they will be fuming that we NPCs are getting in the way. Guys like Peter Thiel and his paid flunky J D Vance have explicitly called for turning the world into a feudal technocracy run by CEOs, with no nation-states; just a patchwork of city-states controlled by the uberrich*. It's an insane dream but they won't give it up in a hurry, possibly not til their corpses are dragged out of their high-tech redoubts in and fed to New Zealand parrots**.
* it's all very Snow Crash. Guys, that was a PARODY, and a warning.
**there's a carnivorous NZ parrot, so no indigestion need occur
Pappenheimer
I'm pretty happy to have my prediction of the House / Senate right on the nose this morning.
Kotek won by 6% instead of 1%. Polling was sparse in her race, so I did not have as much data as I needed in her case ;) Oregon democratic base is very unsatisfied with Kotek, but hated Drazan even more.
My first avocation (of 4, like in the host's short story, tongue in cheek here) is *very* statistics-driven. My IT guy laughs at me for breaking Excel with large datasets on a regular basis.
Those ships were going completely counter to the current trend towards distributed firepower. Look at what the British are planning to replace their destroyers - command and control ships with lots of large unmanned accompanying ships. I don't know whether they are doing the right thing but that is an acceleration of current trends.
Dems also gained > 300 state legislative seats +ten statehouse majorities flipped. And now will have 30 governorships.* This is a true heart of power and GOP gerrymanders actually wound up hurting them. The biggest victories of the night include ten new statehouse majorities:
Georgia House, Michigan House, Minnesota House
New Hampshire House, New Hampshire Senate
North Carolina House
Pennsylvania Senate
Texas House
Wisconsin Assembly
Wisconsin Senate
* NOTE! Elsewhere I've spoken how the US COUNCIL OF GOVERNORS could be an emergency backup locus of elected sovereignty, shout we ever see shit truly hit the fan. There are even five or so REPUBLICAN governors who seem to be smart and decent people. In a terrible situation, they might - in some outrageous situation -refuse to federalize their state guard units and let courts rule it out later.
I've seen it said that there will be enough Democrat governments to enact the 'National Popular Vote Compact' , which would mean the Presidency gets decided by popular vote, which means... bye, bye Electoral College
Mississippi senate vote is looking a lot more promising than it was.
"enough Democrat governments to enact the 'National Popular Vote Compact'"
Republicans might actually prefer that if it looks as if Texas's electoral votes might go to a Democrat.
Keas are cockatoos with attitude, who will devour you with good humour.
(and you know the 'three raccoons in a trench coat' meme? I once saw three keas co-ordinating to make off with someone's goretex jacket. They almost managed it, too!)
Similarly, there will be Democrats thinking(?) that being close to all those electoral college votes might come in handy.
We shall see what happens.
Yah. I'm impressed.
I'm also tickled.
I just hope Democrats don't make the mistake of thinking the voters who punished Republicans this time are thinking like Democrats. They aren't. We all have something in common at the moment (we are pissed off), but that will vanish when the cause does.
Vance 'throwing Two Scoops under the bus"? Nah.
What this means is that it's not Trump holding Vance's kompromat, but likely Putin or Thiel or both. And they are porotecting their investment while Trump rails and foams in vain.
https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/04/politics/jd-vance-trump-2028-campaign
As a trained scientist, do you ever subject your kompromat theory to scientific standards? Ever check its predictive power against events like, say, the Iran war? In science, if someone’s theory keeps changing after the fact, and they present no evidence other than “feels”, what would you call that person? Crackpot maybe?
There is, of course, the possibility that more than one fraction holds Kompromat. With connections to Israel popping up now and then in the Epstein case, I could imagine that Bibi has kindly reminded Trump of certain... evidence, too.
Us Scott Galloway anybody with power? But let's be honest. I'd be satisfied with Musk being exiled to Mars.
"A word after a word after a word is power"
- Margaret Atwood
The human interpretation leads to civilization.
GenAI's interpretation leads to a Shoggoth.
By their fruits...
The Republicans have won the popular vote how often in last 50 years? Of course we could expect changes in voting turnout if voters all know their vote will count, no matter how safely red or blue their state is.
The National Popular Vote Compact is a great idea but it must be combined with overturning the Reapportionment Act of 1929 which limited the total number of representatives in the House (and by extension the electoral college) to 435 members.
Replace the 1929 Act with the Wyoming Rule whereas the number of representative per state is determined by the least populated state (Wyoming) with each state receiving a number of representatives equal to their population multiple of the population of Wyoming.
This results in an increase n the number of House members to 578. Again the Dems get most of the increase in numbers which results in an even tighter lock on the house of 326 Dems to 251 MAGA/GOP . A permanent 75 seat advantage to the Dems in the House and the Electoral college.
National Popular Vote Interstate Compact itself is an agreement among a group of U.S. states and the District of Columbia to award all their electoral votes to whichever presidential ticket wins the overall popular vote in the 50 states and the District of Columbia. The compact is designed to ensure that the candidate who receives the most votes nationwide is elected president, and it would come into effect only when it would guarantee that outcome.
In effect it nullifies the Electoral College making the election of a president democratic. Because of winner-take-all, presidential candidates only pay attention to voters in closely divided battleground states. In 2024, 94% of the general-election campaign events took place in just seven states. That is, 43 states and 80% of U.S. voters were on the sidelines.
It is is actually rather close to passing. National Popular Vote has been enacted into law by 18 jurisdictions, including 6 small states (DC, DE, HI, ME, RI, VT), 9 medium-sized states (CO, CT, MD, MA, MN, NJ, NM, OR, WA), and 3 big states (CA, IL, NY). These jurisdictions have 209 of the 270 electoral votes needed to activate the law. It has also passed in legislative chambers in 7 additional states with 74 electoral votes (AR, AZ, MI, NC, NV, OK, VA). Over 3,800 state legislators have sponsored or cast a recorded vote in favor of it.
What has not been widely reported is that Democrats now control 30 governorships and match state legislatures. They now have the votes to pass the NPVIC.
Now that we have fixed congress and the electoral college, let's fix the dysfunctional and corrupt Supreme court.
Start by increasing its membership to 13, the same number of appellate courts (12 regional courts and 1 national courts).
Chose one judge from every appellate court with each member chosen for a term of 26 years, roughly matching modern tenures (for justices who have retired or served in recent decades, the average tenure is about 28.2 years for terms since 1993). The chief justice cold be chosen from the national appellate court.
Every two years through rotation, a chief justice would retire after 26 years and be replaced. So every president gets at least 2 supreme court appointments by - no more Mitch McConnel crap.
The make up and views of the supreme court would change over time as they should, but slowly as they must.
Should a chief justice die or otherwise leave the bench, a special appointment can be made to serve out the remainder of the judge's 26 year term.
Thus we restore sanity and stability to the Supreme Court.
As part of the transition, after the addition of 4 new justices from the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th appellate courts, the current SC judges will serve the remainder of 26 years and begin being replaced starting with a judge from the 5th appellate court, and so on:
Clarence Thomas ~35 years
John G. Roberts Jr. (Chief Justice) ~21 years
Samuel A. Alito Jr. ~20 years
Sonia Sotomayor ~17 years
Elena Kagan ~16 years
Neil M. Gorsuch ~9 years
Brett M. Kavanaugh ~8 years
Amy Coney Barrett ~6 years
Ketanji Brown Jackson June 30, 2022 ~4 years
So long Clarence. He would go immediately and be replaced by a judge from the 5th appellate court
And in 5 years, Roberts would be replace by a new Chief Justice from the National appellate court.
Alito would be replaced in 6 years by a new justice from the 6th appellate court.
And so on and so forth for 22 years until Jackson is replaced by a judge from the 12th appellate court.
Afterwards the regular 2 year transitions would continue.
Happy Guy Fawkes Day across the pond.
Some have been known to venerate Shoggoths...
"So every president gets at least 2 supreme court appointments by - no more Mitch McConnel crap."
Make it clear that a refusal of the Senate to take a vote at all constitutes "consent" by default.
And a belated (10/25) St. Crispin's Day.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-yZNMWFqvM
After watching this speech you will have an uncontrollable urge to invade France.
Celt, let me say, historically, it Isn't worth the trouble.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/05/opinion/elon-musk-midterms-trump-results.html
...
Talarico, in turn, sometimes seemed to be running as much against Musk as against Paxton. Even before he won the Democratic nomination, he railed against Musk’s greed, saying: “The reason poverty exists in the wealthiest country on earth is not because we can’t feed the poor. It’s because we can’t satisfy the rich. But what we can do is tax trillionaires out of existence.”
...
Just sayin'
"After watching this speech you will have an uncontrollable urge to invade France."
- And marry into their royal house, and have your (French) queen bitch at you when you threaten to have just a few city fathers of Calais hung, as any medieval monarch would, after 11 months of siege....
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Burghers_of_Calais
Pappenheimer
P.S. it's weird how seldom Tours, Rocroi and Verdun come up when internet people discuss invading France. I guess having one's derriere handed to one doesn't fit the narrative.
I invite you all to be careful with Talarico's message. I get that there is anger at a certain multi-billionaire. It's earned. However...
Take a peek at how California voters think about punitive taxation before that and consider a more nuanced message. Here are some of our proposition votes. Democrats here are obviously not ALL on board against billionaires and I don't just mean the rich Democrats who hold elected offices.
Prop. 39: Voter ID.
Funded largely by Illinois billionaire Richard Uihlein.
More than 60% of voters opposing.
Prop. 40: The “billionaire tax”.
SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West got the measure on the ballot.
Just over 56% of voters opposing.
Prop. 41: The Anti-Prop 40 Prop.
Creates stricter rules about new California taxes. If 40 and 41 pass, the one with more votes dominates.
About 53% of voters opposing.
Prop. 42: Blocks on future taxes on wealth, investment accounts, and personal property.
Another anti-Prop 40 Prop. If 40 and 42 pass, the one with more votes dominates.
Just over 54% favoring.
Prop. 43: Blocks on future local citizen-drive tax measures by increasing victory margin to two-thirds.
Two-thirds voting margins almost never happen here, so this would effectively ban.
Just over 54% of voters opposing.
Prop. 44: Health clinic spending requirements. 90% of their annual revenue on patient care.
Backed by SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West.
More than 81% of voters opposing.
Prop. 45: Pare down CA environmental review law (CEQA). Pitched as being about affordable housing and infrastructure projects.
More than 54% of voters opposing.
For those non-USian's here, there are enough Democrats in California to make the Republicans an endangered species. If a ballot measure sounds like something Democrats would pitch... and it is losing... we are NOT unified behind it.
Better numbers...
Prop 39: No 59%
Prop 40: No 55%
Prop 41: No 53%
Prop 42: Yes 54%
Prop 43: No 55%
Prop 44: No 81% *
Prop 45: No 55%
* For the particular union backing this, they REALLY misjudged us. That kind of margin only happens when Democrats and Republicans around here actually AGREE. Someone should be fired for wasting their money.
So it is fine to tax people on the wealth that is in their house - but not on their shares and investments
Strange I would have thought that wealth and investments were more liquid than the house you live in
Do you remember our Prop 13? It was enacted before I moved here, but it severely curtailed property tax growth too. I suspect if there had been a prop about real estate related taxes, that would have shown a similar behavior.
Our State taxes are actually pretty high compared to the other 49 states. The Progressives have a lot of ideas that are generally 'good things to do', but we aren't fans of paying for them through taxes. Who is? Some might ask that... but we DO pay the State and act as a net donor to the Feds who ask for much more.
One of the outcomes I rather like is we've increased the rainy day limit. I remember getting a tax refund many years ago when the surplus blew past that limit and thinking... this is kinda dumb. I get the idea of returning excess, but I've been here during lean years and it's a political dumpster fire every time.
For the record, I voted no on 40, not because I necessarily disagree with taxing wealth, but because it didn't seem like this particularly implementation was going to work out legally and I'd rather the state not spend resources in court for years over it (I also voted no on 41 and 42). I also wasn't entirely sure doing it as a one time tax would be the right way to do it. I do suspect a lot of people who voted against it were worried about either lost tax revenue (I was less so, I suspect these folks mostly do a good job of dodging taxes anyhow), or in fear that the way it was implemented would have allowed it to affect them in the longer run (there was a lot of fear mongering about it affecting people's 401ks and such), rather that because they really object to taxing wealth.
If the billionaires didn't have so many ways to get around being taxed there wouldn't be so much need to come up with workarounds like a wealth tax in the first place.
I have always thought that the correct way to tax extreme wealth was through effective inheritance and gift taxes. But it would need reforms to company law first.
"I invite you all to be careful with Talarico's message. I get that there is anger at a certain multi-billionaire. It's earned. However..."
I suspect that Talarico is engaging in a bit of exuberance of the moment. Contrary to the Republican narrative, Democrats are not communists. "Tax them out of existence," isn't going to be taken literally. I suspect the meaning behind the hype is that corrupt hoarding of wealth will not be tolerated as it was. "There's a new sheriff in town."
...and I think the other half of Talarico's statement was more to the point.
“The reason poverty exists in the wealthiest country on earth is not because we can’t feed the poor. It’s because we can’t satisfy the rich."
Nail on the head, in fact.
I found this article https://time.com/archive/6878209/now-the-morning-after-for-democrats/ from November 1974 very similar to the headlines today.
"Democrats could have danced all night, and some of them did, as the champagne corks popped and the band played on in hotels and headquarters across the nation on Nov. 5. But on the morning after their sweeping election victories, most Democrats recognized that they had received no mandate from the American electorate. Because of Watergate and the economy, voters either protested by staying home or indicated with their ballots that at this particular point in the life of the country, they surely loved Republicans the less but not necessarily Democrats the more."
The (other) Brin spent over $200M in ads to move polling for CA measure 40 from 56% in favor to 56% opposed. Sergey had already proven to be a snake with his changes in Google's search function and implementation of AI-based ads. With this political ad spend, he has certainly opened the door for more political resistance to his brand.
There are no good billionaires, lest we forget.
Been busy. Some answers after this. First are you getting spammed by lefty ragings against Chuck Schumer? Dig-it, most of the Blue Wave was won by moderate dems seizing seats in red districts. Like Vice Admiral Eileen Laubacher. She is now the Congresswoman Elect for Colorado's 4th District. AND as a bonus she booted that creature Boebert from the House! Yet none of them are howling against the left wing…
…the way so many from the left are now howling on social media.
Want to discuss/argue priorities within our grand Democratic coalition? The only alliance that can save the USA and world from surging oligarchy and environmental disaster and injustice? SURE! Want someone younger than Chuck Schumer? Let’s see who you propose!
OTOH, boy are those desperate Kremlin basement trolls pouring out a lot of divisive splitter-crap.
Answers: The blackmail theory remains the only one that is ALWAYS consistent with all observations. And with THREE GOP reps testifying to “Republican orgies.” And much more.
While the KGB are the experts and likely hold most of it, I believe Trump collected kompromat voluntarily given by every eager-ambitious cabinet member. And Mossad? Sure, maybe some there.
“The National Popular Vote Compact is a great idea but it must be combined with overturning the Reapportionment Act of 1929 which limited the total number of representatives in the House (and by extension the electoral college) to 435 members.”
The NPVC is so inherently flawed at all levels I deem it a trap offered by enemies. But yes, The Wyoming Act is one of my 35 proposals.
Prop 40 was flawed, agreed. But 42 gave zillionaires such a huge pass that it means they never have to negotiate. It is my one great disappointment this time.
Reason: “I have always thought that the correct way to tax extreme wealth was through effective inheritance and gift taxes. But it would need reforms to company law first.” I generally agree. NO to rule by spoiled inheritance brats!
DSmelser what bullshit rationalization! Thanks. I got a good chuckle.
Yes, my cousin has gone dark side.
Texas just turned blue. If this isn't a mandate to do something, what is? And note that your snippet mentioned voters staying home. They didn't. Also, "indicated with their ballots that at this particular point in the life of the country, they surely loved Republicans the less but not necessarily Democrats the more" is a confusing sentence. Did voters add commentary on their ballots?
Pappenheimer
While at the Soc. Sec. office yesterday I was present while a young woman melted down because she needed a SS card to complete her job application, and couldn't get one that day. She said she was 18.
With 2 kids.
And there are christofascist 'influencers' calling for women to have more children than they can afford.
Like that?
Pappenheimer
Pappenheimer:
"Did voters add commentary on their ballots?"
No, but the polling did suggest that the public doesn't have a good view of the Democratic Party, and that Tuesday was the result of backlash against Republicans rather than embracing of Democratic policy.
I'm ecstatic about the Blue Tsunami/Red Wedding/whatever, but if we're to have a future, Democrats should know that we've been given a chance to show what we can do for people. They don't already love us. And if we blow the chance, we'll be the bums to throw out again.
Democrats are like the X-Men, "Hated and feared by the people they're sworn to protect."
"And note that your snippet mentioned voters staying home. They didn't."
On this, now, you make an excellent point. Whatever else happened Tuesday, apathy was nowhere in sight.
"And there are christofascist 'influencers' calling for women to have more children than they can afford."
I don't think they expect the women in question to have jobs.
https://www.electoral-vote.com/evp2026/Items/Nov06-2.html
...thanks to Gov. Gavin Newsom (D-CA) and the five seats he effectively stole by redrawing California's maps, the blue team has won this round of the redistricting wars. Maybe, just maybe, this will be the impetus for federal anti-gerrymandering legislation, so we can put an end to this nonsense once and for all.
That's been my position all along. I don't favor Democratic gerrymandering on principle, but I do favor giving as good as we get with an eye toward encouraging something like a national end to gerrymandering--something that can only come to pass when Republicans have cause to sign on.
Meh. They aren't going to sign on.
Everyone understands that when Trump is gone the anger against him will fade.
What I find most amusing is the GOP attempt to rig seats didn't work well enough and the Dem response to it likely wasn't necessary. Still... the GOP did rig seats. Some kind of response was necessary.
Y'all have until 2030 before we revert to different maps. Use your time wisely.
Larry,
I have to wonder what a 'satisfied' rich person would look like to Talarico.
Newly rich people are generally lucky risk takers. Those behavioral traits don't vanish if a wad of cash lands on them. Most likely they are amplified.
Second generation rich people are generally risk-averse and avoid situations where luck plays a big role. They make money through rent-seeking and defending it from those who would take it. Their conservative behaviors don't vanish as the dividends trickle in. Most likely they are amplified.
The only mandate I see says... "Stop It!"
What 'it' is can be lawyered a bit.
The thing about responses is you don't really know whether they are necessary or not until after the event.
'Using the time' involves delivering on promises, and persuading voters what they have now is preferable to what they had.
Alfred Differ:
"I have to wonder what a 'satisfied' rich person would look like to Talarico."
I think we're looking at this in different ways, and that mine is closer to the candidate's than yours.
If I'm reading you right, you're thinking he's talking about being "satisfied" with business success. "When are you going to stop making so much money?" That sort of thing.
I'm expecting he's talking about being "satisfied" with the money that one has made or are making legitimately without having to indulge in further corruption, bribing politicians to rig the rules in one's favor without regard to the surrounding civilization. A different sort of thing.
"Everyone understands that when Trump is gone the anger against him will fade.
Republicans think they'll have Latinos back? Or Dearborn Michigan Arabs?
Remember, much of their baked-in advantage was due to their overwhelming takeover of state legislatures just in time for the 2010 census. And now they've lost much of that, just in time for the 2030 census. I can see them suddenly arguing for fair maps, as opposed to Democrats doing to them what they did to us.
If not, then I'm for giving as good as we get districting-wise.
"Still... the GOP did rig seats. Some kind of response was necessary."
And the supreme court has ruled that political gerrymandering is within the rules. As Robert Doyle's character in The Sting put it, "What was I going to do? Call him for cheating better than me in front of the others?"
According to teh intertubes, the next WH chief of staff will be....Stephen Miller!
Pappenheimer
Mmm...
Then indict them on corruption and bribing and etc?
Yes. The system is rigged to make it very difficult to convict people of crimes. Expensive too. Won't be easy, but it is far safer for the body politic if we do rather than trying to take the money they use for corruption and bribing without prior convictions.
I see what you are pointing out. It's just that the step rich people take into corruption and bribing often starts defensively. I've seen it up close. It is often tied to a judgement someone else has about unethical decisions that don't constitute and actual crime... and something most be done about it.
I can construct arguments against taxation methods pretty much no matter what the method is and what is being taxed. The least stinky argument involves a flat tax everyone pays no matter what, but that sucks for the poor. Other ideas just get worse and I invite you to think on that when it comes to our ballot props that were about taxation. We are somewhat supportive of bond measures lately because the buyers (who tend to be very rich people or retirement funds) do so voluntarily. We wrinkle our noses at the taxation ones... but not always.
Let’s see who you propose!
Ossof?
Yes. That shows very well what they intend to do.
The main reason I turned my computational psychohistory focus to the past was the short half-life of successive priors going forward (it all goes kablooey).
But another reason was that FOUNDATION pretty much laid things out anyway, starting from Gibbon and Hilton.
You need more than that. You need an independent electoral commission like they have in Australia.
A trivial but actual question. Did people use the term "lawyer up" before the 1990s tv show NYPD Blue?
https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=lawyer+up&year_start=1800&year_end=2022&corpus=en&smoothing=3
Took off around 2000.
I wonder. The phrase was used often on NYPD Blue, which ran from (IIRC) 1993 through most of that decade. I'm thinking that's what popularized it.
Probably true. Authors DO change the language faster than the rest of us do.
Mongoose is one of the best essayists in America. An interesting and goodnews outcome from the midterm election is hardly mentioned by anyone. Under the Twelfth Amendment, if no presidential candidate wins an Electoral College majority, the House picks the president, but under a bizarre rule. Each state’s delegation casts a single vote. It takes 26 states to choose the next president in that case. As The Mongoose explains: “That arithmetic sat behind the 2020 pressure campaign on Mike Pence.” Analyst Shankar Narayan counts the incoming House and finds that Republicans capped at 22 delegations, with Democrats holding 24 and possibly 25. And hence that scenario seems bleak for GOP stunts in ’28.
As he points out, there are SO many fad memes out there. One of the worst is the National Electoral BVote Compact... nice sounding at a 5th grade level and spectacularly dumb at the level where shenanigens of a DOZEN different kinds can wreck it completely to the republic's deep harm.
Right now, the toxic storm (much of it Moscow brewed) is a meme spew of hate aimed at Democratic leaders, especially Chuck Schumer. Want to replace him? There are many deserving candidates and it's fine by me, as long as we ditch the sanctimony masturbation and stay together...
...as Dems did in 2021-22, the one year they had actual power in the last 15... when Bernie+Liz+AOC worked CLOSELY with Pelosi+Schumer + Biden to pass Miracle Bills THAT NONE OF THE SCHUMER-HATERS COULD DESCRIBE IF THEIR LIVES DEPENDED ON IT.
That's okay i guess, your privilege. but sanctimony ravings are not supported by facts. and if chuck steps down it should be with our thanks.
Here's the mongoose essays.
https://substack.com/redirect/3a95dbb5-5e2e-4490-aeca-b1c97a8f372c?
New guys want to fire management who just helped propel their party to the biggest landslide since Watergate. Or maybe I should use “their party” more advisedly; there’s a chunk of DSA who don’t care if Republicans or Democrats win, if it can’t be them in charge.
I don't think it is unusual for rookies to want to displace the veterans. It obviously can't work when the election wave is small, but I've think I've seen this pattern in the last three big ones.
Give them time. Veterans don't get to be veterans without some skill at persuading rookies.
Christian and Alfred
It's not a clear relationship but people do "age" and your congress should be made of people who are mostly in the high performing ages - over 40 and under 60 would be my "WAG" as to what that means
Not all of them but most of them
While I get the need to curb excessive enthusiasms when the blood is flowing, I'm not sure what the issue with a 'National Electoral Vote Compact' is. Not that such a decision is going to be made on this blog, but imagine: people rank voting for a President...
OK, what was that about curbing?
Seriously, though, since you have concerns, a post discussing the potential 'shenanigans' would be timely, and of interest; to this fifth grader, at least.
I think most of the inter-party anger with Schumer has to do with his uncritical support for Israel, not foreign interference. Same to lesser extent with Jefferies.
With Bibi looking like he is on the way out and AIPAC funding going dark or moving to United Democracy Project, I think it is too early to see clearly where Democratic Party / Israeli governmental relations will be in a year. But the Dem base are very clearly angry with anyone with close Israeli ties in light of the abuse handed out from Bibi's government. Current Congressional leadership change may be the price of compromise within the caucus.
I do not feel strongly about either Schumer or Jefferies, other than to note that Jefferies did a better job of recruiting candidates and keeping party loyalty on votes than Schumer did. But Jefferies is worse on messaging to the media than Schumer. Neither is awful, except at meme warfare.
Alfred,
Rookies don't become veterans if the latter strangle them in their cradle. I think that is at least a part of the conflict as is the one between the wings of the party.
Some here might remember that after the 2024 election, I posted a letter to the Chicago Tribune from a Latino Trump voter explaining that he voted for Trump because liberals anger him by saying "Latinx", and because his own mother had to work hard as an illegal alien to avoid deportation, so why should today's illegals have a better time? (I'm not kidding)
I'm not holding my breath, but I'd be really interested to know where that guy's head is at today.
"Republicans capped at 22 delegations, with Democrats holding 24 and possibly 25. And hence that scenario seems bleak for GOP stunts in ’28"
That's excellent news that I hadn't thought of.
One caution, though. We'd have to hold that majority in the 2028 election, because the NEW congress is sworn in on Jan 3, and they'll decide the presidential race if so required.
If Steve Miller is the face of the GOP for the next two years we can be confident of another blow out in 2028
Oger don't know s**t about Democrats, who tend to be very feisty individualists without much (or any) party discipline. The diametric opposite of Republicans, who are now the most tightly disciplined partisan movement in US history. And hence one of the biggest reasons for my concluding it's blackmail. Otherwise half of DC GOPpers now would be excoriating Trump. None are. Case pretty much close.
In 2021-22 Bernie and Liz worked their asses off WITH Schumer -Pelosi-Biden, to keep the coalition together. The fact that no one remembers that - or what they accomplished that ONE year they had power - is just plain sad and dangerous.
Matthew you meant INTRA party. Thanks for giving a balanced view. But Israel ranks way down on concerns of most Democrats.
BERNIE FOR MAJORITY LEADER! I am fine with that! It would silence the damned far-left freaks and he could make lots of deals till senility kicks in. But then, the last three DNC chairs came from the Left and that didn't change the sanctimony wailing one bit. (At least some of it has been traced to Russia.)
Tony With this Supreme Court, ANY National "Compact" result that favored Dems would be ruled unconstitutional and any result favoring GOP would be allowed. And there are SO many ways to tweak/allow/forbid. It's a flat out disaster. In contrast, the Wyoming Rule would pass easily with no ways to rule against it.
Yes, LH. The Latino voters who betrayed Kamala out of cultural distaste were fools who came back hard and turned Texas blue. Fine. Forgiven. But the far-lefties who pushed "Latinx" and goddam PRONOUNS offended Spanish speakers like crazy and they are now defending every stoopid tactic because it lets them circle-jerk each other. As they are doing now. Turning a circle jerk into a circular firing squad.
"It would silence the damned far-left freaks..." for maybe a day. Democrats are cats, impossible to herd. Republicans are lemmings.
Andy Weir is terrific and a friend, so please don't tell him... but I've got to vent. Finally saw PROJECT HAIL MARY and I have to say... (SPOILERS)... almost nothing about it makes any sense. The eater-dot-phages have murky and even contradictory explications. The mission premise is odd. The timing is illogical. (A LATER ship would have been sent with better tech that would likely have lapped or passed him. Certainly a robotic phage-collector would have been shot faster/ahead of him.) Rocky's people are obviously more advanced, yet the human ship does all the work. And the human ship took along no SETI contact protocols and language programs? The eridanians don't have radio? TOP priority would be a vast antenna left at the rim of the Tau Ceti system to convey reports back home in real time... and... And the Tau Ceti carbon-source planet is so different from Venus that the life forms could not thrive there... though harvesting/USING the phages would launch a new industrial age.... and...
Might have given a nod to Fred Hoyle's THE BLACK CLOUD. Just a book on a shelf, even.
Please leave all that here in comments? Had to vent but I will not undermine Andy publicly. THE MARTIAN was so-so-so-good!
As it happens, I've been mulling over a story with some plot overlaps about Freeman Dyson's plant life colonizing Europa type moons... Ah well
Geez look online at all the PTD out there... Post-Trumpatic Disorder....
The problem with that starts with “should be made of”. We agree on some things like being human, not insane, etc. I doubt we agree on age.
US FAA says it will phase out floppy disks from air traffic control by 2028
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2026/11/faa-to-finally-ditch-floppy-disks-in-what-it-calls-historic-tech-upgrade/
"But Israel ranks way down on concerns of most Democrats."
When they think about it, many of my fellow Democratic voters do have anger toward Israel over the Palestinian issue. I can't think of a single No-Kings rally I attended which did not have some loud "Free Palestine!" posters among the anti-Trump ones, and it concerned me that even in the middle of a Trump hegemony, that anti-Israel anger seemed to be directed at Democrats.
However, I firmly believe that that particular issue was hyped to a frenzy in 2024 via social media, and it doesn't take much to convince me that much of that was Russia's doing. Zelenskyy did us a huge favor taking out Russian bot-farms by targeting AI facilities.
I wouldn't say that Israel is absent from the minds of Dem voters, but Dr Brin is correct that the issue is nowhere near the importance that it represented in 2024.
"But the far-lefties who pushed "Latinx" and goddam PRONOUNS offended Spanish speakers like crazy and they are now defending every stoopid tactic because it lets them circle-jerk each other. As they are doing now. Turning a circle jerk into a circular firing squad."
Well, I was never one of THOSE lefties, and as far as I'm concerned, the sooner they (metaphorically) shoot each other the better. But that sort of thing was never a campaign issue from Democratic candidates themselves. And voters who let anger at loudmouths on Twitter cause them to cut off their own noses in order to spite such lefties--I hope THEY learned their lesson. There are some things more important to oppose than "Latinx" and pronouns.
"Finally saw PROJECT HAIL MARY and I have to say... (SPOILERS)... almost nothing about it makes any sense."
The book was better, and I'm glad I read it first. It might not overcome all of your complaints, but I think the novel made a better case for itself.
I really hope, you are right and I am wrong, David.
Because I don't believe that sternly worded letters and corporate-friendly politics will save us.
Have to agree with LH - a little less handwavy on the phages.
Not clear that Rocky's people are across-the-board more advanced - more advanced in materials sciences, less in other areas (particularly physics).
"Grace" doesn't make much sense - in either book. Yeah - cool - amateur astronomer, smart guy, science teacher, blah blah - he's not being selected for the mission. There's 8 billion of us. We can find 20 or 100 mission specialists. No reason to train only one team. But he makes literary sense (to not have a new PoV character), so that one gets a pass.
"more advanced in materials sciences, less in other areas (particularly physics)."
In the book, it was a significant plot point that they had no concept of radiation. I don't think that made it into the movie.
The film definitely left out some aspects of the story that would definitely make the viewer uncomfortable. The manner in which the protagonist finds himself aboard ship with no memory and with only dead companions is one of those things.
"But he makes literary sense (to not have a new PoV character), so that one gets a pass."
Yes, if you think in terms of "Out of all the people on earth, what are the odds that they pick our protagonist?", it boggles the mind.
OTOH, if you think in terms of, "The story was written so that the one who eventually gets picked is the protagonist," well, then that's very different.
My daughter and I enjoyed Rocky, and the story kind of made sense with some funny and moving scenes (look up how 'Sign of the Times' got into the karaoke session) but, yeah, the science was more fantasy than fiction.
... and it followed the Hollywood tradition (pioneered by 'Interstellar') of 'not looking up' at the *real* global problems we face.
The Martian was more grounded, except for the scene setting sandstorm that would have barely got the flagpole ropes frapping in reality (this is what threw Chris Hadfield about it, as well)
Ah yes, hadn't thought of the SC. Until McConnell's horcruxes are dealt with, I doubt even the supposedly straightforward 'Wyoming Rule' will be allowed.
Still, that doesn't mean these changes shouldn't be considered, and assessed.
"The Martian was more grounded, except for the scene setting sandstorm ..."
I also thought the Chinese rescue ship was available so quickly as to be a dues ex machina. I have not read that book, but I suspect it didn't happen all that quickly in the novel.
A lot of people were confused by the movie. I wrote it off (mostly) as the kind of thing that is a sure best when adapting hard science fiction stories.
The rule I learned is that a movie script starts at about 120 pages. If it is bigger than that, someone paid to have it written and intends to produce the film already. They might have the money lined up. If it's bigger, though, it's probably still under 180 pages.
Imagine trying to adapt several hundred pages of what is almost science communication from Andy Weir to fit that limit. You don't get the same story. It's related at best. If you have to squint to see the relation, then it gets a "based on the story by" somewhere in the description later.
-----
As for why there was only one ship, I remember seeing an explanation for it. Obviously it wasn't in the movie, but I don't think it should have been. Grace is our POV most of the time. Assert a reason or not and he'd still never know.
Happy "Fall of the Berlin Wall" Day.
The European 9/11.
I do solemnly swear that if I ever become the king of psychohistory processors, I will not get honeypotted.
GOP Congresses in this century have been the LAZIEST in history. Amid lavish recesses, the House would start its week on Tuesday around noon and end it soon after noon Thursday. Republican members were under the "rules" first established by Newt Gingrich when he banned the impartial Office of Technology Assessment (OTA).* Then Newt was betrayed and replaced by far worse -Dennis "Friend to Boys" Hastert. (Look him up. GOPpers almost always choose monsters as Speaker.)
Those rules:
- Members of the Republican caucus may never, ever negotiate with Democrats without permission, or even have friendships with Dem colleagues.
- They must not live in DC but keep their families in the home district, so their children won't go to school with the children of Democrats and so that travel will take up a full day each week.
- Committee meetings will be tightly controlled by caucus leaders. All subpoena requests must be approved and none for Democrats.**
- Deviations from discipline will be punished. LOOK at the expressions of disgust and despair on the faces of at least 5 Republican senators when they voted - en-masse - for Trump's clown car cabinet of monsters! What could have made them do that? The reason is likely...
- THREE retiring Repub representatives spoke of GOP "orgies". Several have alluded to kompromat coercion. Hence a party whose upper layers are disciplined by fear.
And hence, my drum beat for months has been for Dem candidates and new officeholders to WATCH YOUR BACKS and keep your pants zipped! It's one more reason to be giddy over the election of so many retired military officers, scientists and especially women! Come on Putin. Send your honeypot lures now!
* Re-establishing OTA should be a major Dem priority. They don’t face a veto over that! See the full list of my own proposed Newer Deal tactics and reforms. https://davidbrin.blogspot.com/2025/11/the-contract-part-three-aggressive.html
** Likewise for a change in use of subpoenas that could SHATTER GOP discipline by empowering all members individually!
Oger: "I really hope, you are right and I am wrong, David.
Because I don't believe that sternly worded letters and corporate-friendly politics will save us."
I'm truly not sure what to make of such obstinacy. I offer PROOF and facts that Democratic leaders have been very active and accomplished a lot when voters empowered them... and you stick to reciting a standard chant.
Ok so what exactly is wrong with effectively abolishing the electoral college?
I think Dr Brin is afraid that some states will renege on the compact and that the Republican supreme court will let them. Or something more insidious that I'm not thinking of.
LH is right. In fact they needn't renege. The states that don't sign the compact are under no obligations. It is just about the dumbest thing I have EVER seen. It doesn't add up in any way
"The states that don't sign the compact are under no obligations."
Well, that in itself is not a problem as long as the states that do sign have more than 270 electoral votes between them.
The scenario I was envisioning was that (say) Pennsylvania or even Texas turns red again and decides to ignore the compact that they did sign and give their votes to the Republican anyway. It may be that the compact allows them to be penalized in some way for that, but not necessarily that their electoral votes don't stand. And you are correct that the current supreme court will allow anything that helps Republicans.
Ha ha! If they did it right, it’s the boiling-a-frog problem. Guys are guys and flattery works very well.
Your proof is difficult to see thus doesn’t sway a prior belief.
I’ve seen feisty Democrats up close so my priors have already adjusted. I’ve also met feisty Republicans, though. What I tend to say is that each faction is a mix of zealots, negotiators, and corrupt bastards. The difference is in the ratios.
Apply a little Game Theory. The decision tables aren’t complicated.
Peter Diamandis can be a bit irritating with his "Abundance!" paeans that "Happy Days are inevitable!" I dissect that extreme... and doomerism... in AIlien Minds, along with variants and where I think some paths may exist toward a soft landing. But in this posting he offers a much-needed perspective on how many past crises score as deeper pits than the one that vexes us, today.I agree with that... though alas, we today lack the luxury of TIME to work things out. To get things wrong and then learn and do them right. AI MIGHT shorten that learning curve, or fill it with broken glass.
https://metatrends.substack.com/p/weve-seen-this-before-many-times?utm_id=977
"The states that don't sign the compact are under no obligations" (to award their electoral votes to the PV winner).
If I understand correctly, that would not matter; the majority of state electoral votes would still go the the PV winner. Ergo, PV winner wins.
Not that I disagree with you that the whole thing isn't going to fly. The legal obstacles are the main problem, and the current SC would leap on those like a colorful metaphor. One the main issues is that the US Constitution, while it allows each state to implement its own system of voting (within limitation), contains nothing about a state attempting to reflect the voting intent of any other state.
Pappenheimer
P.S. fully expecting an AI bubble popping in the future*, because AI investment dwarfs any reasonable AI return by a massive factor. It's tulips all the way down.
*on the key question of when, insert shrug emoji. Forecasting the weather was much easier than forecasting human decisions because water molecules are not constantly looking at other water molecules to see what they should do. I think.
There is a very good precedent for inter-state treaties intended to enable a broader level of cooperation that bypasses something said in the US Constitution. Look up the history around Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) agreements.
It's not something that was done in the distant past and then left on a shelf. The system lives and breathes as markets change. The most recent stressor I know about involves how LLC's are handled when their founders don't do everything quite right. (Ask me how I know this and you'll re-open an old wound of mine.)
Good. Shell out some $ for better metsat coverage and bigger/faster NWS computers, while we're at it. Compared to the Euro systems, we're slipping into stone knives/bearskins territory.
Pappenheimer
The EC was instituted to mollify the slave states.
As such it's an unnecessary relic and the president should be chosen by popular vote just like mayors and governors.
"the US Constitution, while it allows each state to implement its own system of voting (within limitation), contains nothing about a state attempting to reflect the voting intent of any other state."
Well, as has been mentioned before, what the Constitution allows is for each state to implement its own system of deciding which electors to send. There's no requirement that it involves a state-wide popular vote, and for a few decades at the beginning, most state legislatures simply chose their electors themselves.
There's nothing explicitly prohibiting states from declaring that their method of choosing electors depends on the result of the nation-wide popular vote. The tricky legal part is whether such a compact is truly binding on states that "change their mind".
Say Texas was part of the compact, and in a future election, a Democrat had exactly 300 electoral votes (including all the compact states), but a future Republican Texas legislature says "fuck you!" and declares its EVs to go for the Republican in defiance of the compact. Now the Democrat only has something like 264 votes, and so no longer wins. In what manner could that outcome be reversed? By what legal mechanism? Who would have standing to sue?
And if the compact is breached, what may other states then do?
I see how this could turn into a legal mess, especially if voters feel the compact is being forced upon them rather than something they want in the first place.
From a Paul Krugman newsletter on the fall of the cybertruck:
...
Yet there is an even wider cultural context here. The Cybertruck was the physical embodiment of a dystopian ideology that has become dominant among billionaire tech bros — an ideology that draws heavily from cyberpunk novels and movies.
Wait, can fiction really have major political consequences? Of course it can. Fifteen years ago, you couldn’t really understand the behavior of many right-wing influencers until you realized how their thinking about the world was shaped by reading Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged in their youth. Well, today’s tech billionaires grew up reading William Gibson and watching Blade Runner. But rather than taking cyberpunk’s visions of dystopia as cautionary tales, they saw them as manifestos. And with the great power that flows from great wealth, they have been trying to turn their adolescent dreams into reality.
...
Emphasis mine.
The worst thing about the tech billionaires is that they were the guys who got wedgies in gym class. And they are still pissed off about it.
Forget about blade runner, try revenge of the nerds
Texas could do that now. There is no law that states an EC delegate has to vote for the candidate that won his state. Rogue electors have happened before.
Way back when the earth was cooling in 1984, the nerds in Revenge of the Nerds were sympathetic characters and their antics were "punching up" against bullies.
Today's techbros became the bullies and think that "punching down" is hilariously humorous.
Immature and easy to honeypot. They believe that wealth=wisdom and complexity=power. Forget swords; ignore the lessons of Forth at your peril.
Homo Erectus had a 2M year run with a half-sized brain.
I would not recommend watching revenge of the nerds again.
A lot of that movie has not aged well and are no longer considered funny.
Neither have a lot of other movies from that era.
"A lot of that movie has not aged well and are no longer considered funny."
Much of that is the punching up vs punching down thing. Even the "nerd saw me naked" bit was punching up against (sorority) bullies back then. I'm sure it comes off differently to a modern audience.
"Neither have a lot of other movies from that era."
I have to admit, bad liberal as it makes me, that I still have a soft spot for "Animal House" and "Blazing Saddles". But I know better than to watch such movies with my daughter.
A key issue with techbros that leads to their penchant for trying to make over society to their designs, is the same problem you see with many "smart" people of any type. From professors to business magnates. They are smart about a particular subject matter which has allowed them to excel. They come to believe that they are smart about everything and know better than anyone else what needs to be done to achieve the shining future they have determined is best for society.
In the case of your typical person that delusion might make them annoyingly opinionated on occasion. In the special case of techbros, when you combine that delusion with their extreme power and wealth you can get serious problems. They have the capabilities to actually take actions to implement their vision that affects the lives of everyone in significant ways. Those affects aren't necessarily bad, sometimes they are good even. But sometimes they are very bad. The real problem is that no one else, or at least very few others, get to be a part of the process. This is unfair as everyone is affected, but gets no say. It is also stupid to rely on one person with one point of view to accurately predict the effects of implementing any given plan of action, or for evaluating whether or not the vision is good or bad.
Leading a company to develop a reusable space launch system that could lead to some significant changes to our society isn't what I am talking about. I'm talking about said techbro believing he knows best how the US government should operate and, given the chance actually takes a stab at implementing his beliefs (DOGE, buying politicians). Not advancing technology but attempting to impose an ideology.
I don't think the underlying reason techbros do these sorts of things is because they are evil, greedy or power hungry. Those things may certainly be in play, but the underlying reason is that their past experience of being among the smartest, most successful and luckiest in a certain field of endeavor has caused them to believe that they are smarter than everybody else about everything. I'm also saying that this isn't unique among techbros, but that it is a common human failing. It's when this failing is combined with the money and power to instantiate their ideas at a level that affects us all that it becomes a serious problem.
That's why billionaires tend to suck. It isn't so much that they are different. It's that their money makes them like a bull in a China shop compared to ordinary people. It's the money. Not just that money corrupts, but that it amplifies actions, or even just opinions, out of all proportion compared to everyone else.
"They come to believe that they are smart about everything and know better than anyone else what needs to be done to achieve the shining future they have determined is best for society."
While I'm not disagreeing, that still doesn't explain why many of them think that a dystopia is in fact best for our society.
LOL, I'm sure your daughter can handle those movies. The one positive thing I can say about Trump at this point is that he had some success moving America out of this pearl-clutching, moralistic, culture-policing and -cancelling mode for a while, but I'm sure people who think like Celt will be doubling down going forward. Maybe what you need is an AI specially designed to analyze every piece of culture ever made and generate a list of ways it is "problematic" to progressive sensibilities. And of course it will need to be constantly retrained to keep up to date on what is currently acceptable. Ah shit, some group of do-gooder busy-bodies is probably working on it as we speak.
I worry less about the nerdy-oligarchs and proto-feudalists wanting NEUROMANCER than about those who want A CANTICLE FOR LIEBOWITZ, idiotically thinking the masses will turn against nerds and folks who know how to fix stuff, instead of cracking open prepper fortresses for the juicy meat inside.
BTW I just wrote the intro to the special edition of A CANTICLE FOR LIEBOWITZ.
Well, I didn't try to explain that. Plenty of unkempt slobs in their parents basement also get off on dystopian cosplay, as well as plenty of young left-leaning people. It's one of those human things, not unique to techbros. Unless you want to make that a defining characteristic necessary to be categorized as a techbro.
Not to mention that I'd need to see some clear evidence that believing that a dystopia is in fact best for our society is truly the case for any techbros. Acting in ways that could bring about a dystopia is not equivalent, and certainly doesn't demonstrate, a belief that a dystopia is best for society. It is more likely that a techbro acting in such a way is simply wrong about what the results of their actions would be, haven't thought about such long term results at all, or that they don't care what the results would be.
I wonder how much of the bad things people like Musk do is down to poor communication
Musk appears to be able to superbly lead teams of engineers and scientists - techno nerds
With "normal people" he seems to be a complete disaster - Twitter/X and Doge
Just a thought
Should.
Look up the portion of the US Constitution that has had the most amendment attempts that failed. I'll wait.
VERY likely.
People who think he has no engineering skills are completely missing the obvious. He does... and he thinks a lot of other kinds of problems can be engineered.
That was one of the first stories of its kind my mother got me to read... while I was a kid. Very different experience than when I re-read it years later, but parts of it haunted me as I grew up. Brr.
They are smart about a particular subject matter which has allowed them to excel.
There is a joke that goes something like...
A physicist (usually a guy) walks into a room where economists are discussing their current research. Once they notice the physicist, they immediately start throwing things at him... even the ones who don't know him. He blurts something about spherical cows and runs.
That's it. That's the whole joke.
It's funny if you know us.
--------
Darryl E,
What you are describing is positively ancient. Change the labels and it applies to each generation.
Hi Alfred - EVERY problem can be "engineered" - you just have to tweak slowly and carefully while monitoring what is going on
Probably the biggest issue is that "the world" does not lie to - but people DO
YOU can try to engineer every problem... if you have a death wish.
My wife gets very annoyed when I try to engineer her problems. 8)
The point I'm making should be obvious to anyone with an EQ above 70. Problems can be worked upon. Sure. Use techniques appropriate for inanimate things on people, however, and they get pissed off. Tell me that Musk truly understands this. 8)
"Evil is treating other people like things."
- Granny Weatherwax
You know who also tried to engineer everything (and failed)? The communists....
The problem is NOT that we cannot "engineer" things - the problem is that the people who end up "in charge" cannot fix things
It is inherent in the way that these things work - the people who concentrate on fixing things do NOT get promoted while the people who concentrate on being promoted DO get promoted
This is why the odd person who did NOT go through the usual process seems to be able to manage to do things that nobody else can - IMHO it is NOT because Musk is that good - it is because the other CEOs are that bloody awful
I agree with Alfred - Musk is crap at dealing with "normal" people
"The only reason psychology students don't have to do more and harder mathematics than physics students is because the mathematicians haven't yet discovered ways of dealing with problems as hard as those in psychology."
- John Kemeny
And dozens of pithy quips from all those SF books about psychohistory.
Well, here in Germany, psychology is very statistics-driven, 90% or so I am told.
Don't wish to ruffle any feathers, but I'm with Mark Twain on statistics. Also statistical mechanics. Also probabilistic AI (vs neurosymbolic centaurs). Also Asimovian psychohistory. And especially computational psychohistory.
IMHO it is NOT because Musk is that good - it is because the other CEOs are that bloody awful
At least for the auto industry, I second that. Former Vice Chancellor Robert Habeck predicted that VW would be in trouble If they do not adapt, they ignored it, and now they are in trouble.
Alfred,
Yes indeed, it is ancient. No doubt the underlying traits that give rise to it, right down to the neurotransmitters involved, evolved before H. sapiens came to be.
Granny Weatherwax was spot on... but I don't think Musk treats people as things. He treats problems as potentially solvable and does it in a way that some FEEL like he doesn't recognize their dignity.
I think the full quote from Bismark* is useful here.
Politics is the art of the possible, the attainable - the art of the next best.
It's an art... not an engineering skill. That's where Musk misses the mark.
The rest of what he does is an all-to-understandable reaction to how others are responding to what they see, hear, and fear.
* We don't have to like him to recognize his political skill.
Heh. The lies told with statistics are best blamed on the human story tellers with axes to grind. After that come the folks with partial understandings of what statistics can and can't do.
I don't want to diss on my fellow physicists, but our mathematics isn't all that hard for most of it. It's also a jumbled, patchwork mess. Anyone trying to code a complex physical scenario runs into both.
I'm with you on that. I'd bet it's pretty common among all mammals. I think it confers an evolutionary advantage born from mating attempts.
"It's an art... not an engineering skill. That's where Musk misses the mark."
What I find troublesome about Musk is that he seems to feel that concern over possible failure modes and their consequences just slows things down. "Move fast and break things," even when the things that might break are both important and difficult to put back together again.
It's a problem when you treat people as "things" that can cavalierly be broken.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v49Pxsshz1o
"The Ballad of Stephen Miller"
Warning: If you listen to this country tune, you'll be hearing "Stephen Miller is an asshole..." in your head for the next week.
Problem 1: huge frequentist assumptions such as randomness and independence. I worked with natural gas supercompressibility. Millions of dollars would be lost if molecules were assumed to be independent billiard balls.
Problem 2: sneaky capitalizing on the human nature to round off and over simplify. "Considered accurate to within 3%, 19 times out of 20". What if a gamma ray burst happens in that 20 time??
Engineers!
I had been working in industry for 12 years when moved to Cummins - I was superb at "Problem Solving" - so I was not happy to be sent on a Problem Solving Course
It was bloody amazing!!
A "Seven Step" system - designed to ensure that the engineers did it properly
The first steps were about identifying the problem - they required the engineers to actually TALK to people and make sure that they understood the actual problem
I had NOT realised just how poor engineers are at doing this!!!
The middle steps were useful
The last two - testing the solution and WRITING IT UP
Were also things that engineers are awful at
To me it looks as if Musk is great about leading his teams on the middle bits - and crap at the first bit - which is the bit that involves a lot of talking to people
Alfred,
I think you're giving Nole Skum a bit more credit than he deserves in re: his attitude towards humanity in general.
"Since 2016, Musk has insisted that the probability of our world being a non-simulated reality is just “one in billions.”
Musk (and his techbro investors) have "...been operating as though they are the main characters in a video game, one in which everyone who don’t have their wealth and worldview just don’t matter. (And life is pretty easy once you are a billionaire — the difficulty mode is definitely set to “casual.”) The rest of us, from assembly workers and baristas to lawyers and politicians, are just NPCs, filling out the backdrop of their adventurous, simulated lives. A thing just hasn’t been tried until one of the real players has tried it."
https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/on-elon-musk-and-npcs
I suspect that a ketamine-addled billionaire isn't a person one can rely on to have any inkling of, or empathy for, the lives of us "NPCs". He is also having to come to terms, at age 55, with the probability that he's not going to live forever on Mars (or anywhere else).
Pappenheimer
P.S. If this sounds harsh, remember that this putz has invested large sums into UKIP and AfD, before dumping a little less than $0.5 billion this year to try to save the MAGA stranglehold on the US Government. Fascists only have empathy for their own.
P.P.S. Can I use the term 'putz' if I'm not Jewish? If not, please replace it with t the word 'banchut', which is a bit harsher but appropriate to having spent part of my childhood in Calcutta.
Post a Comment